@jlengstorf @Netlify ... so my instinct is that it's a little code funny that I can't spot right now. Have you explored this reference? I cloned it and got it working immediately. Perhaps there might be a good tip in there somewhere.
https://github.com/imorente/gatsby-netlify-form-example
My tweets and posts live here on my own domain these days.
You can explore them here and follow me on Mastodon instead of Twitter where I'm not currently active.